1
History 104A, September 26: Gold leads to Art, Philosophy, Perfection
and even War.
First of all, the gamers association -- I thought it was a
gaming club
-- going out and shooting deer or something. The gamers
association
at Ohlone is holding a Texas hold em poker tournament
Friday,
cafeteria, September 30th, starting at 1:00. The games start
at
2:00. The sign-ups is at 1:00 or it
goes until 9:00 o'clock or
until you
lose all your money. Noncash
prizes only. Proceeds to go
to the
hurricane fund Katrina. If any of
you are interested in
playing
poker, since nobody seems to have any classes on Friday
afternoons. Does anybody
have a class on Friday afternoon?
I take it
back. Four of you do. Okay. We are preparing, coming down for the
exam that is
scheduled for Friday. We have a
group meeting Wednesday,
and some of you still have to turn in papers from
missing the last
group
meeting, just as a reminder.
We left off with the defeat of the Persians during what was
called the
Persian wars in 479 BCE. And we
are now going into what
has been
known as the golden age of Greece.
Building economics,
social life,
peace, part of what we refer to as a golden age, which is
going to
somewhat end in about 50-60 years with the Peloponnesian
wars. Peloponnesia, if you recall, is the peninsula that Sparta is
located on
in southern Greece. And this is
the war between Athens and
Sparta,
between the land power, Sparta, and the sea power, Athens.
What happens
at the end of the Persian wars is the beginning of
Athenian
imperialism. Athens feeling its
oats, feels superior because
of the
defeat of Persia begins to not only about an alliance between
2
cities, but
begins to force certain cities to join when at the name
the Delian
League, for the office like NATO, National Atlantic Treaty
Organization. It is the
alliance quote/unquote of free states, not
quite so
free. Fearful of Athens, as they
always were distrustful of
those New
York liberals or San Francisco liberals, Sparta retaliates
by creating
a Peloponnesian league, a league of basically monarchies,
aristocracies, and more the landlocked powers, although they do
identify
with certain colonies overseas.
During this expansion of
Athens
wealth booms into the city and a tremendous construction
projects are
undertaken, including the building of the Acropolis from
wood and
miner buildings to major monuments, major structures made out
of
rock. And the most famous of which
is the Parthenon.
The Parthenon is dedicated to Sparta, Athena. And there was
supposed to
be a statute in there some 80 feet high covered in gold
army that
was dedicated to Athena. The
Parthenon stood for a thousand
years until
about 1800 when Greeks went to war with Turkey. And the
Greeks kept
their munitions there, and the Turks bombarded it and much
of it blew
up. You can see it right behind me
here on the hill --
well, you
can't see it too well. My batteries
are dead, up on top
they're sort
of faded in the background.
An individual in the period of 1800 ADCE Greek declared its
independence
from Turkey and again war broke out and that was part of
the reason for
it. Many Englishmen, romanticizing
Greece, including
lord Byron
the poet, went to war there.
Another man, Elgin, and he
proceeded to
bring back to the British museum what were known as the
3
Elgin
marbles which are many of the pieces of the artwork that were on
the
Parthenon along the edges. Now,
the Parthenon is a fascinating
structure
because it very much reflects the Greek attitude in life,
perfection,
but the image of perfection, not necessarily the reality.
The Greeks
looked at everything from a sort of intellectual
perspective. And the
Parthenon was built in such a way that from the
city, the
distances between the columns looked even, the shape of the
columns
looked straight up and down. In
reality, mathematically, they
had figured
out how to create that imaging by creating different
features. The columns would
buckle sort of in the middle. The
steps
would be a
little uneven and slightly bent, so it would look perfect;
in other
words, the striving for perfection and certainly during the
golden age. And that's
another element that I would add to Greek life
with the
hubris, the fates, the polis, is the striving for perfection.
The 1950 comic book heroes were perfect. They were super men and
even Batman
had his perfection, maybe a little perverted with Robin,
but we can't
be sure. Has anybody seen the new
Batman movie yet? Any
good? The 1950s was a period where people
strived for perfection.
You lived
for only two groupings. One was
the working class group
that were
imperfect, and I'm talking the ivy league look. You sat in
a classroom
like in the 1950s and everybody looked alike. Basically
everybody
had crew cuts or flat tops, buttoned down shirts, and the
girls had
madras dress and penny loafers for men and women and that's
the way you
dressed. They looked like Rich
Cunningham from Happy
Days/Nickelodeon again. And
the women and the working class blue
4
color group,
when they went through college, they didn't go. We have
working
class people today that didn't go to college. They wore blue
genes,
T-shirts with cigarettes rolled up in the sleeves. They had
the long
hair and sort of the Fronzerilli motorcycle jackets. The
women in
that group wore pedal pushers, white sneakers, sort of like
Grease with
the jackets that were too big for them with the gang names
on the
back. In the 1960s, and Superman
we went through an era that
was similar
to the Hellenistic area in Greece.
We began to look at
the particulars individually. Today we see the long hair, short hair,
beards, side
burns, and that's just on the women.
Differences in
choice and
appearance. Spiderman was not the
perfect body. He was a
brooding
hero, always feeling guilty, having trouble sleeping. He
didn't have
that superman perfection. And he
even wound up with
women,
living with a woman as well. Of
course, as I said, superman
was faster
than a speeding bullet and don't mess around with women
until
basically the 1970s, but that's another story for those who know
their comic
book heroes.
The Greeks even set the perfections of their heroes and they're
Gods into a
ratio so that you had a certain ratio -- two, three,
seven --
anybody remember the ratio they used?
For the head, for the
body, for
the arm? It was all done to create
a certain level of
perfection. This was an am
imagining of life. And again goes
back to
what I said
earlier -- well, maybe I didn't develop this. I talked
about hubris
and not being as good as the Gods, and I talked about
fate. I didn't identify the difference
between Greek Gods and our
5
Gods. Our Gods are images we are supposed to
adhere to. We try to
achieve the
perfection of our Gods. Our Gods
are trustworthy,
healthy,
loyal, cheerful, obedient, and reverent.
They're all good.
To the
Greeks, their Gods were something above humankind. You were
not to
emulate them or imitate them because that would be committing
hubris. What they did, you
would not do. If Zeus ran around
with
other women
and turned himself into a swan or became a snake and
impregnated
Alexander's mother so that it was a half God, we could not
therefore run
around with women because that would be committing a
crime of
thinking that they were as good as the Gods. So it was not
looking up
to them in that sense. They simply
existed, which is
difficult
again for many of us to understand.
And so that perfection
of the
Parthenon or the attempt at making an imaging of perfection was
that same
imaging that existed in Greek society.
During most of this golden age in the building and development
the council,
the man who reflect Athenian democracy was Pericles who
we have at
least a report of his words defending and identifying what
democracy
was all about. Pericles received a
lot of advise from his
mistress who
was educated and well read. She
was not Greek. Greek
women, as I
said, were to be in the homes bearing children. Pericles'
mistress
Aspasia A-S-P-A-S-C-I-A I think was a Persian and of the
class of
high class prostitutes. She was a
Geisha girl in a sense
like in
Japan, highly educated, well dressed, or what we call I guess
in some
cities, high paid escorts. Yes,
prostitution, the oldest
profession
has existed since Lilith as we talked about earlier in the
6
semester.
The Athenians, as I mentioned, created an educational system that
pretty much
allowed the parents to dictate what the education would
be. And there was this conflict that was
occurring in the background
with
Sparta. In the year 43l BCE Athens
and Sparta went to war. That
war was
devastating for lots of Greeks because of the allied cities.
The Spartans
pretty well devastated the Athenian army, but Athens had
its walls
and could hide in its city; however, at around 429 BCE a
plague broke
out, perhaps the bubonic plague, wipes out a large
portion of
the city and within some time even killing Pericles, the
counsel of
Athens. Yet Athens continued to
hold behind the wall of
the city and
the Spartans had control of the outside carry. The
Spartans
decided to build ships to cut off the trade that was coming
into
Athens. And by 404 BCE, a war for
almost 30 years, the Athenians
finally fell
to the Spartans. The Spartans were
magnanimous in the
fact they didn't destroy Athens or
didn't burn it to the ground or
occupy it
for very long. What they do was
set up a government of
Athenians
who were favorable to the Spartan philosophy. They created
a puppet
government, if you will. It was,
at this time, that a man
named
Socrates ran into trouble.
Now understand that many times in the books you'll read that
Socrates was
a free thinker, that he believed in promoting democracy
and
that was this opposition to the Spartan government, that he was a
sophists. None of that is
actually valid. Socrates we have
some idea
of what his
philosophy was from his best known student, Plato. He
7
believed in
a republic which was a system where an elite group ruled
and made the
decisions for everyone else because they were
philosophers,
philosopher kings. And it was a
caste system, not an
elected
democratic structure. And when he
had students around him,
when he
questioned people in his Socratic method, he was leading them
into a
direction that we're going to talk about more when we discuss
Plato, a
direction of identifying the superiority of understanding
wisdom,
beauty, and justice. He did not
believe in the Athenian Gods,
the Greek
Gods. And that certainly was detrimental
to the ruling
class now in
Athens who use the Gods to control the people in the
sense
perhaps Carl Marx referred to it, religion is the opium of the
people. And in a church state where the state
dictates to be the
religious
control, they can dictate to you your method of life through
the
religion, and pretty much that's what had now gone on in Athens
In 399 Socrates was brought to trial for basically endangering
the morals
of minors, questioning the establishment.
And as I
indicated,
he was convicted and ordered to take hemlock. And the
jury, as I
indicated, of 501 people gave him the death penalty. He
had the
option of giving an alternative.
And he gave the option, the
alternative
that was to give him a pension for life.
He said he had
lived his
life, he was 70 years old, and he deserved a pension.
The period of 399 to about 353 is still some development, some
art, and
much more creative kind of perfection art in Greece. I
mentioned
one of the most famous statues from the period the
Discabolos,
the discus thrower by a man named Myron showing movement,
8
showing the
perfection of the body, the Hercules with the steroid
looking body
that they did during this period of time.
But the Greek
cities still
prevail, although once again, somewhat under the
dominance of
Sparta at this time. Athens
maintained its economic
trade and
yet had more of a conservative kind of government.
But in the north of Greece, in a place called Macedonia, there
was a new
group arising. And that was the
Macedonians, under Philip
of Macedonia
and later his son Alexander. But
before I move onto
that, I do
want to talk a little about the culture of Greece and some
of the
philosophies, if you will, of ancient Greece including Plato
and
Aristotle. I'm going to cut the
computer for a second because I
want to use
the board here.
The Greeks again perhaps famous for philosophers because of their
belief in
individuality, allowing free thought, emphasizing free
thought,
have come up with every kind of development almost that we
have today
including the atom theory. Again,
it's one of those
periods in
history where the individual was allowed to speculate.
Obviously,
we don't see much development in the way of science, what
we would
refer to them as armchair philosophies.
Another, Aristotle
but quite
different in philosophy, does develop on what we might call
the
beginnings of science in his approach, which is, some
experimentation, some investigation, and some rational thought and
rational
interpretation. Maybe I should
deal with the Greek Gods
first if I
can remember them. Maybe you can
help me here. Who are
some of the
Greek Gods?
9
A Zeus.
THE PROFESSOR: And Zeus was
the chief God, the head God. And
the Roman
name?
A Jupiter.
THE PROFESSOR: The 12
Olympians. Zeus, Jupiter,
identified with
the sun
basically. The oak tree was
identified with Jupiter -- I'm
sorry, with
Zeus and Jupiter. Zeus had two
twin brothers basically or
they looked
like him and it was often difficult to tell the
difference. Who were they? Who were the basic brothers who looked
like him and
when we found statues, we had trouble telling who they
were? One was the God of the sea. And his name? What was the Roman
name for the
God of the sea? Poseidon is the
Greek name. And the
Roman name
-- I'm surprised you didn't pick up on -- Neptune. They
were often
made looking very much alike, but Zeus had a lightning bolt
that he
threw, where Neptune threw the trident, which is a pitch folk
with three
points to it. And of course the
other God identified as
part of that
trinity was Hades, God of the underworld, whose name for
the Romans
was Pluto. Hades reflected
wealth. By way, Neptune was
identified
with the bull and horses, but guarded the sea. Zeus'
wife -- what
was her name? Hera. And the Roman name for Hera was
Juno. She was the God of marriage despite the
fact she had trouble
with her own
and was identified with the God, the mother Goddess also
with the
cow. Any of the other Gods you can
think of?
A Athena.
THE PROFESSOR: We mentioned
earlier Athena was a Goddess of
10
wisdom. She also gave the olive and she was
identified as a warrior
God. And as Goddess of wisdom, what animal
symbolized Athena?
A An elephant.
THE PROFESSOR: An owl. Many years ago I ran a chess program at
a Chinese
school called The Wisdom School. I
developed a logo using
the
owl. But I found out that the owl
is sort of an evil symbol to
the Chinese. It's not that symbol of wisdom, so they
said it was
okay, but
you have to be careful on those things.
What is Athena's
name in
Roman Gods? Minerva without my New
York R at the end,
Minerva. Goddess of
beauty? Did you mention your own
name? I
thought
so. Goddess of beauty? Come on. What's the Roman name for
the Goddess
of beauty? You know this one I'm
sure. We're not
studying any
of these things in your readings?
Q Is it Venus?
THE PROFESSOR: Yes. Venus is the Roman name for the Goddess
of
beauty. Now, you know, yes. But the Greek name for the Goddess of
beauty is
Aphrodite. Messenger of the
Gods? Flew around with wings
on his
heels?
A Hermes.
THE PROFESSOR: Hermes. And the Greek or Roman name or Hermes
was? Mercury. How many have we got?
Some of you are writing them
down. How many have we got so far?
A Four.
A Seven.
THE PROFESSOR: Seven. God of war, that's one that everybody
11
knows too?
A Aries.
THE PROFESSOR: Aries is the
God of war. The Roman name is?
Women are
from Venus and men are from --
A Mars.
THE PROFESSOR: Mars. The God of the smith, the God of fire,
the
God that
loved Venus and who was married to her but she played Sex In
the
City. The Roman name was Vulcan?
A Hephstus.
THE PROFESSOR: Hephstus,
the God of fire, smith of the Gods.
That should
be 10?
A Nine.
THE PROFESSOR: Nine. The God of male beauty and male wisdom?
This God had
body and mind, the Greek concept that you have to have a
sound mind
and a sound body? And
interestingly, the same name in both
Greek and
Roman? Apollo. Goddess of the hunt?
A Athena.
THE PROFESSOR: Athena was
the God of wisdom and wore armor; is
that
correct? The Goddess of the hunt,
the Roman name was Diana and
the Greek
name was Artemis. That's from the
three musketeers. I'm
missing
one. Danged if I can figure out
which one I'm missing. Okay,
we've got 11
of 12 anyway. There were also some
minor deities and
they often fought among themselves, as we
can see in the Trojan war.
And they
took sides in that war.
We started to talk about philosophy. And the first Greek
12
philosopher
that we deal with generally is writing in the -- just
coming out
of the just ages, the archaic sage and his name is Thales.
He's often
described as an absent minded professor, one of those
nerds,
constantly thinking. And they talk
about him one day staring
at the stars
trying to figure out the meaning of life and walking
along and
fell into a well. It is also said
that because of his study
of the
stars, he made a lot of money. We
could tell when various
crops would
be good. We could predict good
weather, poor weather,
probably a
meteorologist if you will. And so
he knew when to tell
people when
to put in large sums of money. And
he apparently became
extremely
wealthy, made use of it practically.
He talked about how
the universe
had originated, observing how a large part of water
played in
nature and how silt developed in the water and standing
water. And he concluded that all life
originated in water. Now,
perhaps it
came from outer space on meteors and landed in the water
and
therefore we have a so called surface now on tonight. And he
believed
that all forms of life would return to water. He believed
that Earth
itself rested on an ocean like a floating block of wood and
that the
heavenly bodies consisted of burning ground and that the moon
received its
life from the sun. Now, remember
this is in the sixth
century BCE,
some of it not quite as accurate.
We don't really -- as
the Earth
lie on an ocean, but close in the sense of the magma and the
floating and
certainly the floating apart of Earth in early millions
of years
ago.
Again, in the early 16th century another Greek philosopher and
13
I'll spell
this one A-N-A-X-I-M-A-N-D-E-R.
Anaximander, he wrote a
book called
Nature. He believed that the first
principles of life
were
infinite and that it embodied all forms of matter. In other
words, he
sort of saw it as the big bang thesis, that the heaven and
Earth all
had their beginnings at that time and they will return. And
also talked
about the rough concept of evolution.
I'm not sure you
need to know
all these names by any means, but to get a feel for
Thales, yes,
Pythagoras, yes, but some of these others, like Heracles
believed
that fire was the primary form of life.
Pythagoras, of
course you
know, of course, because of the Pythagorean theory. He
developed in
474 BC and he migrated to a Greek colony.
His philosophy
fell into
mathematics and science and he organized it to religion. He
belonged to
a discipline sort of like monks in the medieval system.
His whole
basic system was pretty much based on numbers. We developed
geometric
theorems and he felt that a number held its place like for
them --
water, fair, air -- held for the physicists. Numbers were the
primary
methods or the numbers of the expression and he dealt through
numbers. We believed that
the Earth was a sphere, round, and he
studied the
movement of the Earth and he was a firm believer in the
transmigration of souls, the
transmigration of souls. What is
the
transmigration of souls?
What's the word we use for it?
Anybody
here? Anybody ever hear of transmigration of
souls? Or our next
governor's
sister, being Warren Betty or Beatty.
He's saying that
he's going
to run against Arnold. Wouldn't
that be a first, Hollywood
stars
running against each other?
14
A Shirley McClain.
THE PROFESSOR: Who is
famous for her believe in reincarnation.
Transmigration of souls is reincarnation. And he believed that God
was
identified with one, the number one was God. Again, one of those
earlier
philosophies.
Xenophanes -- matter is indestructible, the universe always
existed and
studied fossils. He believed that
the God's crimes were
shameful and
that the stories were false, that Gods had to be
basically
good.
Well, I've got about five minutes.
I think I'm going to jump
ahead --
excerpt Democritus. Democritus was
the one who came up with
the concept
of atoms moving around an empty space and they were all
part and
made up of these atoms, these infinitesimal individual units
called
atoms. Again, we're talking about
the period 2500 years ago.
Plato, fourth century -- basically again, in his republic and
other
writings, we delineate a concept.
To Plato, the universe was
created out
of basic form and it continued to develop and unfold.
This form
was not reality; it was the beginning of reality. If you
will, it was
unreal. And with this form's
expansion, we saw people
who were
becoming an animal, becoming some of whom had more knowledge
of what
Plato called the universals. Here
we had particulars that
came into
being as a becoming and particulars, the parts. The
universals
that a few people could understand were wisdom, perfection,
beauty,
justice. In our world, we had the
imperfect of wisdom,
beauty, and justice,
but a few individuals who were to become the
15
philosopher
kings could understand that perfection.
So Plato, we know
this is a
table. We know it because
somewhere in these universals
there is an
image of a table. And so we
understand what a table is.
We
understand what a cat is. But
they're not perfect. You see this
is that
Greek sense again of that perfection that we can't achieve.
But some
people get closer to it. They
understand it better. And
these are
the people that come out of these cogs, these wheels, these
spokes that
are going to be the rulers of society.
This is reality.
This is what
is. And for Plato, in a sense, one
might say this is
God. And there are people that understand
God on a higher level.
They will be
the rulers. They may come out of
the working class.
They may
come out of the military class.
You go out and test to find
those who
understand it better. It was sort
of like a Mandarin system
where, in
China, they went around and tested the people in the
villages to
see if they could study in the universities and become
part of
society.
Again, to Plato, the universals you cannot understand. Most of
us can't
achieve this knowledge. Most of us
are in the world of
becoming. We see the elephant.
We may understand it. But
the men in
the cave
feeling the trunk, feeling the backside, feeling the tusks,
will put
together something else, but there may be someone who has a
better understanding
of what that elephant is in reality.
And
Aristotle,
although a student of Plato, was just the opposite. That's
what we'll
finish up on on Wednesday.
---oOo---
16